I am quite upset right now. Sad really. I’ve spoken to a
couple people about this and was glad I was told I wasn’t over reacting. I read
a lot of books in my life. MANY. I never review a book I don’t enjoy. No reason
to write a bad review. The world is full of negativity. But, for the first time
in my life I returned an ebook on Amazon. No, I didn’t read it through. I got to
chapter 6 before I just couldn’t go on. I have never returned a book. I tried
so hard! I swear I did. Here’s what happened.
I went in knowing it was going to be a rough read. There
were warnings. However, it became clear, early on, the author likely does not
know how a BDSM relationship works. There are all types. I’m aware. I’m also
not talking out my ass.
I have experience in BDSM. I have friends who are in the
lifestyle, authors who wrote/write BDSM, I’m friendly with quite a few
Dominants and submissives. I participate in the BDSM Blog Hop (as long as I
remember to sign up in time) I tell you this so I’m not accused of not knowing what
I’m talking about.
When you choose to write BDSM it’s not like choosing a
flavor of ice cream. It’s not like choosing to ride the ferris wheel instead of
the tilt a whirl. You are entering a world that is more misunderstood every
day. When people write BDSM wrong you are putting it in people’s heads that
this is what it’s about when in fact it’s the opposite. There’s a difference
between punishment and abuse. It’s a fine line and when you cross it, you might
as well cut it.
I was seriously heartbroken when I read this book.
Insulted, frustrated, and most of all ashamed it was associating itself with
this lifestyle.
I’m BEGGING… BEGGING authors, or anyone who decides they
want to dip their pen in the BDSM world give it the respect it deserves and do
your research. That research will require more than accessing Google. Talk to
people who know. Ask questions. Anyone in the lifestyle would rather you ask
them then guess.
You do SO MUCH HARM when you write what you THINK is BDSM.
You set BDSM back. SO stop. Please. I BEG OF YOU!
Bravo, Mere. Couldn't agree more.
ReplyDeleteI would say to anyone reading/writing BDSM, if the idea of considering an LGBT person mentally disordered because of their sexuality/gender identity horrifies you, why is it okay to assume someone in the BDSM lifestyle is psychologically damaged? BDSM is not therapy, and kink is not "caused" by trauma. That's a harmful -- and way too common -- misconception.
Sorry you got a book that didn't understand that point. Hopefully the next one will be better <3
Thank you, Kate. Your advice is spot on!!!
DeleteGreat commentary. Sorry the book was my great
ReplyDelete